Average Reviews:
(More customer reviews)I must say I've read just about every book on the US Army in the 1850's...and while this book is OK it was little more than the original book by Col. Simpson "Cry Comanchee". I was surpirsed that this book was three times as thick and really offered almost NO new information...furthermore I was very trouble by the author's attmepts to make his work into an easy read novel...a very scarry trend in history today in order to reach the greater public. He describes the gut feelings of men who never left a record of how they felt that morning, nor that they knew this patrol would be different from the rest...I was disappointed as I realized that all the additional pages were filler about conjections of peoples emotions that have been long gone. He even talks about the troopers packing their saddlebags...a quick look at the VERY published inspector General reports of the 2nd shows the companies had no saddlebags! There is little academic research, there has been alot of information of the arms, equipments, etc of the old 2nd Cavalry (now 5th Cavalry) come to light in the last 20 years and it is obvious the author has not spent any real time at the US Cavalry Museum nor researched and primary sources that Col. Simpson didn't already. All in all I am not usually this harsh, but I did pay full price (which was TWICE what I paid for a new copy from the pubilsher of the long out of print "Cry Comanchee") and was very upset. The original publisher still has several copies of "CC" for sale and I sadly must suggest you go to them and buy that book instead.
Click Here to see more reviews about: Jeff Davis's Own: Cavalry, Comanches, and the Battle for the Texas Frontier
0 comments:
Post a Comment